better Image Quality CCD or CMOS ?

Back

Image Sensors
Image Sensors is one of the most important component in today's digital camera either it be a point-&-shoot and a professional dSLR type.

As of this writing. An image sensor is typically a charge-coupled device (CCD) or a complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) active-pixel sensor.

May be in the future, there would be something much better than what we have today.   Perhaps a real High Resolution, High Speed digital camera which are stabilized, with anti-blur, with extreme low light features type of a camera, with 20x or 40x zooming capability that would be no larger than the palm of your hand.

Both types of sensor accomplish the same task of capturing light and converting it into electrical signals.

Neither technology has a clear advantage in image quality. CMOS can potentially be implemented with fewer components, use less power and/or provide faster readout than CCD.

CCD is a more mature technology and is in most respects the equal of CMOS as well.

Performance
There are many factors to consider when evaluating an Image Sensor, which includes its dynamic range, its signal-to-noise ratio, its low-light sensitivity and more.

Basic Consideration
The Larger the image sensor is, the better image quality you get.    Images will have less noise and will obtain greater dynamic range than smaller sensors.

Because of their larger sensors, DSLRs can generally take high-quality pictures at ISO 1600, 3200, or even higher speeds, while compact cameras tend to produce grainy images even at ISO 400.

This problem is exacerbated by pixel count; doubling the number of pixels on the sensor means that each pixel is half the size, and hence noisier.
Summary for CCD and CMOS
High Lights CCD CMOS
Signal out of pixel Electron packet Voltage
Signal out of chip Voltage (analog) Bits (digital)
Signal out of camera Bits (digital) Bits (digital)
Fill factor High Moderate
Amplifier mismatch N/A Moderate
System Noise Low Moderate
System Complexity High Low
Sensor Complexity Low High
Camera components Sensor + multiple support chips + lens Sensor + lens possible, but additional support chips common
Relative R&D cost Lower Higher
Relative system cost Depends on Application Depends on Application
Responsivity Moderate Slightly better
Dynamic Range High Moderate
Uniformity High Low to Moderate
Uniform Shuttering Fast, common Poor
Uniformity High Low to Moderate
Speed Moderate to High Higher
Windowing Limited Extensive
Anti-blooming High to none High
Biasing and Clocking Multiple, higher voltage Single, low-voltage
  • both CCD and CMOS has strong and weak points, image quality can still be achieve by compensated skill, lighting, experience, right angle, understanding of what can and can not be achieve on a given circumstance, alternatives available and perhaps some other factors as well